Customer Reviews
Proper New Jersey boys peddling their papa's pizza. They love what they are doing and it shows. Great pizza, thin crispy east coast style crust. Love it!
M Moss
Google Local Guide
Ordered the frozen pizza. The pizza is amazing. Quick to heat and pizza dough is great. Simple toppings but full of flavor. Would love to try it again at the store next time I am in town. Well deserved praise.
Mark Easley
Google Local Guide
Wish I could give 6 stars. Ordered online from these guys and they shipped all the way out to California. Easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. If you’re looking for a healthy frozen pizza that tastes fresh out of the oven this is it. Can’t wait to reorder and hope I can make it out in person one day and have a bite in real time
Benjamin Titmus
Google Local Guide
As Marvin Gaye once sang, "Ain't Nothing Like the Real Thing." My family has been searching for real NY pizza since we moved to the ATL. We found it here at Carlo's. NY crust...the perfect mix of sauce and cheese. I also love the meatball subs. Could feed 2+ people. Absolutely enormous. Love this place. Makes me feel like I am walking the streets of Manhattan all over again.
Andrew L.
Yelp Review
I ordered Carlo's pizza and just have to say, easily the best frozen pizza I've ever had if not the best pizza in general. I can only imagine how good it is fresh out of the oven on location. I will be making it a point to drop in next time I'm in ATL. Believe the hype!
Manning Demster
Google Review
Our Dad's Legacy
Originally from Wildwood, NJ - The Doo-Wop Capital of the World, Carlo Samuel Accardi opened the doors to his first business, which he named Johnny’s Pizza after his father, and began making pizzas at the corner of 17th St and Surf Ave.
17th & Surf, Wildwood, NJ
A lot of beautiful memories were shared on this corner with both the Accardi and Kennedy Family. As kids this is where we played, had family events and worked our first jobs, folding boxes and selling candy bars. Ever since I can remember I always wanted to be a pizza maker. We proudly bring our Dad's pizza to the ATL so you too can taste the legend!
we are located inside the Historic Sweet Auburn Municipal Market
Market Parking Is Available
Mon - Sat, 11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sunday, Closed
